Wake Forest students on the Hillel and Chabad student executive boards created an online petition early this week urging the administration to cancel an event scheduled for Oct. 7 featuring speaker Rabab Abdulhadi. The petition, which has garnered over 7,000 signatures, pushes for the event to be canceled due to claims of Abdulhadi spreading antisemitic rhetoric and supporting Hamas.
The event, titled “One Year Since al-Aqsa Flood: Reflections on a Year of Genocide and Resistance,” will be held in the ZSR Auditorium on Oct. 7. The date marks the one-year anniversary of Hamas’ surprise attack on Israeli towns bordering the Gaza Strip, resulting in the death of 1,200 Israelis and the capture of more than 200 hostages. Israel’s counterattack has resulted in the death of over 40,000 Palestinians, according to the official Health Ministry.
Five departments are sponsoring the speaker event — Wake Forest University’s Humanities Institute, the department of history, the department of politics & international affairs, the Middle East South Asian studies program and the National Endowment for the Humanities.
Chabad Student President Isabelle Laxer, Hillel Student President Andrew Orfaly, Hillel Treasurer Jake Shulkin, Chabad Executive Board Member Ben Sharon and Hillel Religion & Education Chair Maverick Cortes created the petition in hopes of gathering support for the event’s cancellation through digital signatures.
“We felt we had to do something to draw attention, not just within our community, but also put pressure on those that have the power to make change,” Orfaly said.
Abdulhadi is the founding director and senior scholar of the Arab and Muslim ethnicities and diasporas studies program at San Francisco State University. She is also on the advisory board of the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel.
The Anti-Defamation League and Campus Watch have denounced Abdulhadi for being antisemitic, pushing an anti-Israel agenda and promoting terrorism. She came under fire for organizing a virtual event on Zoom in 2020 featuring Leila Khaled — a member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, which, like Hamas, is a designated foreign terrorist organization by the United States. Khaled is well-known for hijacking a commercial airplane in relation to this group in 1969. The virtual event was eventually canceled by Zoom for violating the platform’s terms of service.
In the first 48 hours of the petition being live, it surpassed 5,000 signatures. The Old Gold & Black could not confirm that Wake Forest students were the only signatories. The undergraduate population is made up of approximately 5,500 students. At the time of publication, the number of signatures on the petition surpassed 7,000.
“We know that a petition alone will not do anything. However, we believe it is a starting point of conversation and awareness,” Laxer said.
According to the Director of the Humanities Institute (HI), Dr. Jennifer Greiman, the lecture was proposed by one of the HI’s interdisciplinary faculty seminars made up of seven faculty members from four different departments. The group researches the topic of “genocide and memory studies.” As the Israel-Hamas war continued, the seminar members felt it was necessary to examine the question of genocide in Gaza and engage with the work of Abdulhadi.
“The seminar then put together a proposal, listing Dr. Abdulhadi’s qualifications and the importance of her scholarship to their seminar, which was evaluated and approved by the Humanities Institute’s faculty committee for co-sponsorship with other departments,” Greiman said. “Such co-sponsorship involves helping to pay travel, lodging, modest honoraria and other expenses.”
A member of the faculty seminar and Rubin Presidential Chair of Jewish History, Barry Trachtenberg, told the Old Gold & Black holding the event on Oct. 7 is an opportunity for scholarly growth.
“Over the last 12 months we’ve heard the claim repeatedly that this was the worst of violence that Jews have suffered since the Holocaust, and I get that — I’m a scholar of the Holocaust; I am Jewish. Oct. 7 was an incredibly horrible day” Trachtenberg said. “We also must recognize that, since then, at least 42,000 Palestinians have been murdered, the vast majority of them being noncombatants. It is the largest loss of life in Palestinian history ever, and I believe that makes it worthwhile for us to be able to talk about it.”
He also expressed his disappointment in the statements being made against Abdulhadi.
“I have seen some of the comments on the petition, and it is heartbreaking to me to see such vile, racist, sexist, Islamophobic statements made without any kind of pushback against a highly respected scholar simply because she’s a Palestinian woman who speaks out about the experience of Palestinians living under Israeli rule,” Trachtenberg said. “I think there’s no place for that in a university setting. I think accusing her of being a terrorist supporter is an extreme form of Islamophobia.”
Greiman explained that she was slightly surprised by the reaction of community members towards the event.
“In the 13 years since the HI was founded at Wake Forest, it has demonstrated a deep and longstanding commitment to Jewish Studies scholarship at Wake Forest, funding about three dozen projects in the broad fields of Jewish studies […],” Greiman said. “I am surprised that there are members of our community who would deny the value of gaining such perspectives on Palestinian society and culture from a Palestinian scholar at this moment in time.”
Laxer and Orfaly shared their concerns that the content of the event would reflect antisemitic sentiments.
“Posters were put up with the Wake Forest logo onto our campus and were being seen by Jewish students,” Laxer said. “Jewish students were getting emailed about this event, and the language in the title was blatantly antisemitic and pro-Hamas. That’s when we felt like we needed to do something and that this event had ventured over from the realm of free speech into the realm of hate speech.”
Laxer continued to emphasize the positive responses that she has received from the petition since it has gone live.
“I’ve felt like I have received an outpour of positive feedback from students feeling that their views have not been heard, and students who didn’t know this was even occurring and are now very upset and want to take action,” Laxer said.
The Old Gold & Black has reached out to administrators for comment and will continue to cover the development of the event.
This is a developing story. The Old Gold & Black will update the article with any new information and statements.
Wake Citizen • Oct 14, 2024 at 9:18 am
Barry Trachtenberg is a joke. It’s a shame that someone of his moral character and lack of knowledge and insight is actually associated with Wake Forest. He tries to sell his opinion as fact. “Distinguished scholar”? That’s opinion. “The University has effectively endorsed the lies, racism and Islamophobia spread by her detractors”. No Barry, she’s not the victim. Maybe the civilized and more educated population at Wake Forest just doesn’t have the same moral values as Professor Rabab Abdulhadi.
Constantly reminding everyone that you’re Jewish and are the Rubin Presidential Chair of Jewish History doesn’t make you right nor does it make you more credible. It doesn’t take a genius to discern between right and wrong. I wish your energy and angst was more directed toward eliminating terrorists from countries all over the world instead of trying to righteously educate the rest of us who already know the truth.
Hey Barry, Gaza called. They want their idiot back.
James Lutzweiler • Oct 1, 2024 at 11:33 pm
So, 8,000 Zionists control academic freedom at WFU? Hilarious!
Concerned parent • Sep 26, 2024 at 8:46 pm
Would you invite the Taliban to speak on 9/11 about the death of civilian Afghans and Iraqis at the hands of US troops? Sure public discourse is valuable but there is a time and a place. Let’s invite her back and put her on stage with a member of the ADL and someone from HI moderating. Let’s hear what she has to say but let’s keep her honest. Just not on a day when we mourn our dead and missing.
A friend of truth • Oct 3, 2024 at 7:53 pm
Dear Concerned Parent,
I would rather hear directly from the Taliban then from CNN or ABC or M NBC or Fox or the New York Times, none of whom are capable of paying for all of their sins at present. I like to get my stories straight from the horses mouth In their own words, not in words filtered by Zionists or anyone else.
You may recall that Osama bin Laden wrote a letter to the American people. Intelligent people can read it and decide for themselves whether or not it has any truth in it. I don’t need the Zionist dominated media to interpret life for me.
student • Oct 7, 2024 at 11:25 am
This is stupid. Stop trying to smear the pro-palestinian by leaving fake comments about bin laden. Pro-palestinians are just random people like you and i — none of us support bin laden lmao.
Zionists gotta try harder with the fake comments!! This one is way too obvious
A Friend of Truth • Oct 8, 2024 at 6:53 pm
If you are replying to A Friend of Truth, come back again after you take an intellectual bath. Happy to engage with you.
antizionist jew • Sep 26, 2024 at 1:46 pm
I want to start a petition that Wake Forest change its motto from pro humanitate to pro pecunia. You can feel whatever way you want about Oct. 7th, but I’m curious what mental gymnastics someone has to do to justify the expansion of the war to Lebanon and beyond? How can anyone stand by at this point after everything that has followed since Oct 7th and think this is not out of control? Is Hamas in the room with us right now? My prayer is that this community can break free from the fascism-lite grip it’s currently in the hold of before it is too late and that all colonialist murder machines destroying our world fall.
student • Sep 26, 2024 at 2:28 pm
Hamas is certainly still in the same room as the 10o+ hostages who remain underground in tunnels in Gaza…
jew who doesnt care for labels • Sep 26, 2024 at 4:56 pm
the “expansion of the war to lebanon” was caused by hezbollah launching missiles daily at israel for about a year now since october 7th. what would you do if someone were shooting rockets at you? let it keep happening? israel has been doing that for 11 months. how can anyone stand by and completley ignore the fact hezbollah has started this… and dont say they are fighting for palestinians. there are 250-400k palestinains in lebanon living as second class citizens, forced to live in refugee camps, unable to work, being used as political pawns. if hezbollah cared for the plight of the palestinian perhaps they would support them, instead of spending millions on rockets to launch at israel incessently..
antizionist jew • Sep 26, 2024 at 10:44 pm
these are decisions being made from governments seemingly completely estranged from and with little regard towards their citizens that cost thousands of innocent people to needlessly die. this includes this country, the us. certainly we can agree that there’s something fundamentally wrong on a human level with that. especially when all labels but that one are set aside, no?
jew who doesnt care for labels • Sep 27, 2024 at 1:02 pm
wow thank you for completely sidestepping everything i said about hezbollah, their constant attacking of israel and them using palestinians as political pawns. it is fundamentally wrong people with little regard towards their citizens make decisions that lead to thousands of people dying, but those people making those decisions without regard to the plight of the palestinian, the israeli, the civilian, are the leaders of hamas, hezbollah, and other iranian proxies. they started these conflicts and what do you expect to happen in response? should israel just lie down? the way towards peace in this region is with the destruction of radical islamist terrorist groups and i hope you can come to understand that. 63% of israelis support the current campaign against hezbollah, because over 100k israelis have been displaced for the last 11 months because hezbollah keeps launching rockets at northern israel, if the US were not to keep supporting israel hundreds of thousands of israelis were to die, the only reason the iron dome has been able to shoot down the 10000+ rorckets is because of OUR tax dollars, if they didnt have the iron dome, hezbollah has launched 10000 rockets at israel since October 7th, where is the outrage my friend? why do we focus on israel? literal victim blaming. I implore you to educate yourself on the tricky realities in this geopolitical situation and understand there is only one political entity protecting its citizens, and it is Israel. The rest just use them as pawns in their hundred year long campaign of jew-hatred and anti semitism. you are not safe in America should they win, hamas’s charter calls for a global islamic caliphate which would literally place us at best as second class citizens ( a la jim crow / apartheid) and at worse 6 feet under the ground (if death is a worse alternative to being slaves)
antiozionist jew • Sep 29, 2024 at 4:36 pm
started these conflicts? are we referring to the same hezbollah that emerged AFTER violent israeli occupations of lebanon? this is about money and control of regional resources. it’s the same story it always is with colonization. it’s awful because BN and his zionist regime exploit and use jewish trauma as a trojan horse for this expansion. you can’t violently occupy and displace people and not expect radicalization and extreme resistance. this is a well documented and well studied pipeline. one way to collapse this pattern is to come back to humanity and examine our own national loyalties. this war is not right and our country is complicit. innocent people are dying in droves and if you think israel or any government won’t use these new warfare strategies (the pagers for example) on its own citizens if we were to demand change, you’re sorely mistaken. look at the building of cop cities all around the us after the BLM movement and ferguson. do you ever consider what it would be like to walk in anyone else’s shoes? particularly…idk an innocent palestinian mother’s for example?
James Lutzweiler • Oct 1, 2024 at 11:31 pm
Well spoken.
A friend of truth • Oct 3, 2024 at 6:28 pm
I will sign it!
Student • Sep 26, 2024 at 11:40 am
It’s utterly disgusting that the OGB is publishing verifiable lies against an esteemed scholar. What a rag. Go write another article about the USNews ranking… apparently anything other than tabloid trash is above the OGB’s paygrade…
Student • Sep 26, 2024 at 12:58 pm
So true. The OGB is publishing verifiable lies. Like how Barry tries to say that October 7 was a terrible day, yet on his instagram justified it by saying that people have the right to resist annihilation. Doesn’t seem like Barry thought the death of jews on that day was so terrible. Also, slight misrepresentation of the statements made by the Director of Humanities Institute without disclosing her relationship with Barry. Would love to know what verifiable lie you think is being published, in fact the article cites to this purported scholar’s credentials.
student • Sep 28, 2024 at 2:08 pm
Lol trust fund kids seething that the tenured jewish director of jewish studies doesn’t buy their genocidal rapist lies
Student • Sep 30, 2024 at 8:06 am
lol great comeback loser – so you don’t believe they were raped. You have no business at Wake Forest and should leave in shame. The school doesn’t need filth like you.
student • Oct 7, 2024 at 11:27 am
You do know that israel has been caught systemically raping palestinians, right? Their whole country rioted for the right to rape. That’s why media outlets dropped the Hamas mass rape Hoax — because Israel is actually doing it.
Student • Sep 30, 2024 at 8:07 am
Great reply, so you dont believe they were raped and just threw out trust fund out of no where. Guessing you are super liberal on everything else, but when it comes to jewish women being raped screw them. You are disgusting and should leave in shame.
student • Oct 7, 2024 at 11:28 am
Lol I’m jewish and a survivor of sexual violence. I just don’t buy into the whole “brown men are rapists” racist fantasy you like to peddle, especially not when Israel has been caught raping thousands of Palestinian hostages. Where’s your shame for lieing?
Olivia • Sep 25, 2024 at 11:47 pm
Hey Barry, we’re not upset she’s coming because she’s Palestinian, or that she will talk about Palestinian suffering. We’re livid you’d invite someone who dared to publish a condemnation statement of Ilhan Omar’s acknowledgement of October 7th, which even Omar characterized as bad thing. We’re livid you’d do it on the first anniversary of that day, while we’re mourning. It’s saddening, because there was a real opportunity to hold space for both Palestinian and Israeli suffering without legitimizing “The Al-Aqsa Flood” massacre, a term coined by Hamas to brand the day as a positive thing. The title of the event itself suggests Oct 7 (the killing of families and raping of girls younger than me in their homes) was a legitimate form of resistance. Humanities should be focused on finding a path to mutual respect, coexistence and a tangible forward— not normalizing the violent murder of Jews for sport, which Hamas jubilantly posted all over the internet. You could have picked a different Palestinian speaker who hasn’t openly supported this day or plane hijackings. You could have sponsored dialogues. You could have platformed someone whose work seeks to one day achieve national self determination for all peoples connected to the land. You and your colleagues chose someone who isn’t interested in any of that, and it’s an insult to academia itself.
Student • Sep 26, 2024 at 11:42 am
The UN Recognizes a right to resist apartheid and colonization. There’s a difference between murder and self-defense.
Worried • Sep 26, 2024 at 12:54 pm
What if self-defense comes in the form of murder? What do you do then? Can’t legitimize mass murder in the name of some high-minded idea of anti-colonial resistance.
google is free • Sep 28, 2024 at 2:07 pm
bro israelis have been shooting palestinian children in the back with live rounds for years… shooting at someone actively ,murdering your community’s children is indeed self defense lol
Concerned student • Sep 26, 2024 at 1:47 pm
is rape resistance?
concerned about your intelligence • Sep 28, 2024 at 2:06 pm
maybe you should ask the israeli rapists whose rape of palestinians is well documented. the un alleged 30 cases of rape by hamas members, with no allegations of systemic abuse. on the other hand, the un has alleged thousands of rapes by israelis!
concerned about your empathy... • Sep 29, 2024 at 12:26 pm
ah yes the UN the same organization that covers up sexual abuse when its peacekeepers commit or, or lets saudi arabia on its human rights council, or does nothing against the uyghur genocide in china. the same organization that “made it illegal” for hezbollah to operate on the border against israel and then proceeded to do nothing for the past 18 years… the same organization that is and has been incredibly biased against israel.. do you really believe those numbers? did you not see pictures of israeli corpses bleeding out of their crotch regions? paraded around gaza with blood leaking whilst palestinians cheered :/. cant have a case when the victim was literally dead, burnt alive, decapitated, hidden, etc. you are right some israeli soldiers have done heinous thing to imprisoned palestinians, and there is a court system literally working to prosecute them as we speak. can the same be said for hamas? no they were literally encouraged to do it, given placards before oct 7 with translations of arabic phrases like “take off your pants” into hebrew. great whataboutism, you completely sidestepped what i said with a different untrue reality. horrible argumentation. maybe next time you will be less mean and a little kinder? believeallwomen right? one organization encourages it, the other prosecutes those who commit it…. equating the two is downright morally reprehensible and disgusting.
Bob • Sep 25, 2024 at 9:07 pm
If nothing else this is cruel, thoughtless and provocative. It is what we have come to expect from liberal universities like Wake Forest. Universities that support and teach their students to embrace terrorists.
You cannot make it up. America once a beacon of light has become a dark room. A place where evil is good, bitter is sweet and darkness is light (to paraphrase Isaiah). And one of the origins of this madness is universities like Wake Forest. A woke univeristy of Hamas supporters. Hamas being a terrorist organization that throws gays off of rooftops. Kills women for dishonouring their family. Where transgenders do not exist. Where, in fact, no other religion other than Islam exists.
Only in a world that has lost its bearings could this utter bullshit be accepted.
“Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the center cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world…”
Thanks to Wake Forest and woke universities like it, this great poem perfectly describes what is happening to the west. Shame on you Wake Forest for your cruelty, thoughtlessness and embrace and promotion of pure evil. If you could feel shame you would be enshrined in the hall fo shame. You are little different than the Univ of Berlin in the late 1930s. F/U.
A Foe of Fables • Oct 4, 2024 at 9:44 am
Rarely is it so easy to respond to comments like Bob’s blather belched here. The poor lad probably knows nothing about settler colonialism. And to call Wake Forest University a promoter of Hamas Is like calling Israel a lover of peace, when in point of fact it comes as close to being the great whore of Babylon as anything since St. John wrote about that Hebrewish harlot in the first century.